I don't see where I said that both years were better than Aiken.
Aiken shot just over 50 eFG% on 28% USG and Shots with an assist rate over 20%. Both players had really nice offensive years as freshmen. Both players aren't highly regarded defensively. I do think the reason why Aiken as a freshman got 1st Team and Boudreaux as a freshman got 2nd Team has to do both with there being a bit of a gap beyond Princeton's three this year than there was beyond Yale's three last year and winning played a role for sure.