SomeGuy
Professor
Posts: 6391
Reg: 11-22-04
|
03-09-17 09:06 AM - Post#225843
In response to penn nation
Yes. While I am a proponent of winning games being something that gets considered (heavily) in terms of who makes first team, I think it should be considered most in instances where a team like Princeton goes 14-0. As we discussed this on the board, there were a few comments that suggested that making the Ivy tournament ought to have some bearing. However, I'm not sure I really see a significant difference between Penn going 6-8 and Dartmouth going 4-10 (and beating Penn twice) -- certainly not one that would be significant enough for me to say that Penn's best player gets equal billing to Dartmouth's best player. If Columbia got the last spot at 5-9, I don't think I'd elevate Petrasek to 1st team just because they made the tournament.
Of course, I presume that not all members of the 2nd team got the same number of votes. I suspect Broudeaux got more votes than Brodeur.
|