Untitled Document
Brown Columbia Cornell Dartmouth Harvard Penn Princeton Yale



Username Post: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed        (Topic#20799)
EasyGreen1 
Freshman
Posts: 16

Age: 40
Reg: 12-08-16
12-06-17 12:14 AM - Post#239187    

Clearly, McLaughlin has not been able to put effective offensive and defensive schemes in place. Here we are, game 6, against Sacred Heart, and the best we can muster is 1 on 1 hero ball, end of shot clock 3s, and weak dispassionate defense.

Why is Chris Knight not starting and playing a lion's share of minutes? Anyone who has seen him play knows that he should. Why are Letoa and Foye playing key minutes, at key points in games, without discernible production(are the coaches even watching these games or tracking stats/efficiency)? Ian Sistare and Cam Smith are more aggressive, competitive, and would be much more productive on both ends of the floor. They have the ability to challenge defenses, open the floor for shooters, get to the rim and the FT line (the upgrade on defense would be immediate). Barry, Wright, Johnson are playing their hearts out. They deserve better. Perhaps giving other experienced players an opportunity to play more, if the current rotation continues to fail, would help. YOU PLAY TO WIN THE GAME!

 
SomeDartmouthStudent 
Freshman
Posts: 61

Reg: 11-30-16
12-06-17 12:52 AM - Post#239189    
    In response to EasyGreen1

I didn't make it to the SH game, but that was just a poorly coached game all around. I'm not sure what we are doing. The biggest no brainer of all time is to give Chris Knight more minutes.

 
SomeDartmouthStudent 
Freshman
Posts: 61

Reg: 11-30-16
12-06-17 12:54 AM - Post#239191    
    In response to SomeDartmouthStudent

Also not to be the bearer of bad Kenpom news, but we are certainly going to drop a lot of spots.

 
hoops123 
Freshman
Posts: 81

Age: 47
Reg: 12-14-16
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-06-17 01:24 AM - Post#239192    
    In response to EasyGreen1

Mclaughlin has put the "laugh" back in Dartmouth basketball. I could only laugh as our players watched SH dribble around at the end of the game for 15 seconds before we fouled them. Pathetically poor coaching. The game was close! We could have won...Has Mclaughlin ever coached before??? I've seen JV high school coaches that have their team foul immediately on the in-bounded ball. To Green's point, this coach has no idea what he's doing out there. Love Mclaughlin hiding behind his borrowed slogan "work hard, work smart, work together". Our team is doing none of the above. If you put a group of 10th graders out on the court that worked hard, worked smart, and worked together, would they beat SH? According to Mclaughlin, that's all you need to do. Talent be damned. Has anyone looked at our box scores for this season and specifically the last two games?? Even I won't write about them because they are so bad. Can anyone tell me why Knight doesn't start and Cam doesn't play??? Honestly, I think Boudreaux got out while the gettin was good. And Mclaughlin owns this sinking program which is officially going backwards...Who's got next Harry??

 
EasyGreen1 
Freshman
Posts: 16

Age: 40
Reg: 12-08-16
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-06-17 02:48 AM - Post#239197    
    In response to hoops123

McLaughlin seems to have surrounded himself with weak assistants who won't speak truth in support of the players or the program. I've heard that he has totally shut out the voices of alums, ex-players, etc and is quite content in his echo chamber of incompetence.

 
Cooper 
Sophomore
Posts: 131

Reg: 11-22-04
12-06-17 10:51 AM - Post#239213    
    In response to EasyGreen1

If that's the case it is curious that McLaughlin has spearheaded a celebration of former coach Dave Faucher next month that will bring a good number of Faucher's players back for a weekend.

 
hoops123 
Freshman
Posts: 81

Age: 47
Reg: 12-14-16
12-07-17 02:43 AM - Post#239452    
    In response to Cooper

I'm sure it'll be a good time catching up with former teammates but...after all the reminiscing is over, what is going to be said in low whispers about Mclaughlin's abysmal coaching and the poor performance of this year's team? Let me guess what Mclaughlin says: "we're getting better as a team", or "you can't change a program overnight", or "if Boudreaux hadn't left....", or, God forbid, "our kids are working harder, and smarter, and more together than ever". I don't think you'll hear "I am having a very difficult time coaching" or "I have no idea how to attack a 1-3-1 zone", or "should I foul the opposing player on the inbound play with 1:45 left and down by 8, or should I have my team wait 15 seconds, try to steal, and therefore effectively do the other teams job of running out the clock?", or perhaps "using Evan Boudreaux as recruiting bait in my first recruiting class has effectively produced 1 out of 5 recruits that should start during their careers." (cue the Chris Knight should start chants) The yea, rah rah, "Dartmouth basketball is great" stuff is fine for a little while, but the giant elephant in the room that weekend is that the Dartmouth Men's Basketball program flew south last winter and isn't expected back to nest this season, next season, or any season soon...

 
SomeGuy 
Postdoc
Posts: 4255

Reg: 11-22-04
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-08-17 10:26 PM - Post#239728    
    In response to hoops123

It's not clear that the program actually is going backwards. Last year, you guys were 305 in kenpom. This year, you are up to 277. Too early to be sure, but there is evidence this is actually better.





 
SomeDartmouthStudent 
Freshman
Posts: 61

Reg: 11-30-16
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-10-17 11:40 PM - Post#239948    
    In response to SomeGuy

You must be missing out on these games. Barely beating Maine is not a good look. I hope we are better, but not passing the eye test on my end yet.

 
SomeGuy 
Postdoc
Posts: 4255

Reg: 11-22-04
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-11-17 06:13 AM - Post#239950    
    In response to SomeDartmouthStudent

Not a good look, certainly, and still bottom 75 nationally. Just marginally better than last year, which isn't saying much.

 
Cooper 
Sophomore
Posts: 131

Reg: 11-22-04
12-11-17 10:41 AM - Post#239960    
    In response to SomeGuy

"Just marginally better than last year, which isn't saying much. "

I'll be the devil's advocate here and say it: With Evan Boudreaux leaving the team and having lost Guilien Smith for the last four games, "marginally better" is an accomplishment.

 
Go Green 
Junior
Posts: 268

Age: 46
Reg: 04-22-10
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-11-17 12:53 PM - Post#239963    
    In response to SomeDartmouthStudent

You do remember that we lost to Maine last season?

And that we didn't get our first victory until December 18?

I'd rather win ugly than lose pretty.

 
EasyGreen1 
Freshman
Posts: 16

Age: 40
Reg: 12-08-16
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-11-17 01:04 PM - Post#239965    
    In response to Go Green

Unfortunately, if the coach refuses to rework his player rotation based on defense, effort, and productivity we'll get our fill of ugly losses. Having watched all the Ivy teams play multiple times, I don't see the Dartmouth squad (as the coach is currently utilizing them) beating any of them even once.

 
Go Green 
Junior
Posts: 268

Age: 46
Reg: 04-22-10
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-11-17 01:11 PM - Post#239967    
    In response to EasyGreen1


Personally, I think you're correct.

My point (perhaps poorly articulated) is that criticizing McLaughlin now is misguided, given that the team is outperforming 2016-17 thus far. The team could very well look like crap in person this year. But they look objectively better in the W-L column than they did last season.

If we go 0-14 in league, then by all means--let McLaughlin have it.

 
EasyGreen1 
Freshman
Posts: 16

Age: 40
Reg: 12-08-16
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-11-17 01:22 PM - Post#239968    
    In response to Go Green

And my point is, there is no need to go 0-14 in Ivy play or lose the remaining nonconference games (except Notre Dame and BC). This team has enough talent to win but too much focus is placed on who can shoot threes and almost no focus on individual or team defense. Our guards are really weak against quick, penetrating guards which causing our big men and Miles to get into early foul trouble. A defensive stopper at PG (10-15 minutes per game) would turn this team around. Cormier used Malik Gill and Cam Smith effectively in that role. Cam's still there (though McLaughlin seems hardly aware).

Edited by EasyGreen1 on 12-11-17 01:24 PM. Reason for edit: No reason given.

 
Silver Maple 
Postdoc
Posts: 2955

Loc: Westfield, New Jersey
Reg: 11-23-04
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-11-17 02:07 PM - Post#239973    
    In response to Go Green

  • Go Green Said:

My point (perhaps poorly articulated) is that criticizing McLaughlin now is misguided, given that the team is outperforming 2016-17 thus far. The team could very well look like crap in person this year. But they look objectively better in the W-L column than they did last season.




Agreed-- it's too early to castigate the coach. Maybe he really is a lousy coach, maybe not. There's no way to know yet, as, to be fair, he's working under extremely difficult circumstances. Give the guy a bit of time to find his way and start creating a basis for long term success before you start calling for his head.

 
SomeGuy 
Postdoc
Posts: 4255

Reg: 11-22-04
Re: McLaughlin too stubborn to succeed
12-11-17 08:42 PM - Post#240001    
    In response to Silver Maple

I'm of the opinion that Dartmouth made a big mistake firing Cormier. I also think that McLaughlin's failure to bring in assistants with D1 coaching experience was a further mistake (though I guess it might not be the coach's failure if nobody with experience wanted in).

That said, tossing the guy out after a little over a year seems extreme. Got to give him a chance. If this wasn't what you wanted, you shouldn't have gone the inexperienced route.

 
SomeDartmouthStudent 
Freshman
Posts: 61

Reg: 11-30-16
12-11-17 11:22 PM - Post#240010    
    In response to SomeGuy

Look- at this point I would hope all the Dartmouth fans want him to succeed. Having been around the program in a near day to day manner, I don't think we are on track. I was around for two years of Cormier and while I certainly didnt like him, he was a better coach.

McLaughlin simply doesn't seem to know what hes doing. I hope he turns it around, but the chips are certainly stacked against him.

Speaking from an enrolled student perspective, I think there were more expectations surrounding the program because we had players like Boudreaux and Wright who showed the potential to be special, yet we never did anything with them. Any momentum we could have had is pretty much gone.

 
hoops123 
Freshman
Posts: 81

Age: 47
Reg: 12-14-16
12-12-17 01:35 AM - Post#240015    
    In response to SomeDartmouthStudent

Basketball is not rocket science. Mclaughlin has supposedly "played the game" (I should look up his stats....) and was a head D2 coach and a D1 asst. I watched our team make team mistakes (not attacking a zone, not playing def with our hands up, poor/no switching on defense, not playing def on the three pt line when a team is killing us, not boxing out, no idea that we have to foul when we are down inside of 2 mins, etc,etc,etc). This is bad coaching. Plain and simple. I too have friends involved in the program. The coach is soft and non-confrontational, does not hold players to high standards, and he is not accountable and neither are his players. And as you well know, there are lots of other issues on this team. So with these obvious flaws known to outside viewers and to those that know the program on the inside, whats next? An odd win against bad opponents, a win against 1 or 2 Ivy's that have a bad day, and an awful record at year end. Am I optimistic? No. I played and coached this game. We can't even handle basic stuff. ND literally could beat us by 50....Am I hopeful that things will turn around? Yes, but I think that's unrealistic given the current state of the program. I too hear other players will leave. Including players recruited by Mclaughlin. When does the new coach "free pass" expire? He had Boudreaux and he let him go (oh and he's going to Xavier, that piddly little 4563 student Jesuit University in Cincinnati that, OH WOW, went to 9 NCAA tourneys in the last 10 years :-(). He has shown he can't handle basic coaching tasks. My question: When does the Athletic Council and Phil Hanlon hold AD Harry Sheehy to the same "standards" that he supposedly holds other coaches to?? He's had a couple of coaching hits, but a lot of misses as well. My guess: no one in the administration particularly cares about men's basketball and whether it is good or not. By the looks of our empty stands at game time, it certainly is not a revenue producing program. Sheehy did a favor for Peter Roby(D79), the AD at Northeastern where Mclaughlin was an asst coach, who asked (or told) him to hire Mclaughlin, and now we're stuck with Mclaughlin. PS Roby retiring next year. Thanks for dumping the coach on us Peter! Since you played, we thought you would do us a favor.... Sheehy had several coaches that were much better than Mclaughlin, with major D1 experience, that he passed on. Sheehy's D3 AD antics have placed Dartmouth players and fans in semi-permanent purgatory where no one actually cares about Dartmouth Mens Basketball (except for the few members of this board and a sprinkling of fans/ex-players from around the country). And of course, for those who think we need to give coach Mac "more time", how much time is that? And, do bad coaches get the same amount of "time" to make their programs good? Do you really give a known bad coach the same amount of time as a known good coach to improve your program? I say NO WAY... ugh...Enough self flagellation for one night...

 
SomeGuy 
Postdoc
Posts: 4255

Reg: 11-22-04
12-12-17 06:39 AM - Post#240017    
    In response to hoops123

I'm of the opinion that once you hire a coach who obviously will need to grow into the job, you need to let him grow into the job. If they can keep improving, I would stick to it. Admittedly I prefer to stick to a plan. I think a lot of teams across sports shoot themselves in the foot by cycling through coaches too often.

 
Icon Legend Permissions Topic Options
Report Post

Quote Post

Quick Reply

Print Topic

Email Topic

749 Views




Copyright © 2004-2012 Basketball U. Terms of Use for our Site and Privacy Policy are applicable to you. All rights reserved.
Basketball U. and its subsidiaries are not affiliated in any way with any NCAA athletic conference or member institution.
FusionBB™ Version 2.1 | ©2003-2007 InteractivePHP, Inc.
Execution time: 0.086 seconds.   Total Queries: 17   Zlib Compression is on.
All times are (GMT -0500) Eastern. Current time is 02:00 PM
Top